How to Speak Up to a Senior Colleague About Safety

Four steps for speaking up to a senior colleague about safety, from a question to a stop, with the words for each step and what to do when the first try fails.

Knowing how to speak up to a senior colleague about safety is a skill, not a personality trait. Quiet people do it well once they have the words. The method most hospitals teach is graded assertiveness: you start with a question, and if the risk is not fixed you move up, step by step, until you reach a clear stop. This article gives you the four steps, the words for each, and one example about a missed hand wash, because that is the one you will face first.

Why silence causes harm

When a serious incident is reviewed afterwards, a familiar finding is that someone in the room had noticed the problem and said nothing. They thought they must be wrong, that the senior person must know something they did not, or that it was not their place. The hierarchy that keeps a ward running also keeps mouths closed.

The maths is simple. If you speak and you are wrong, you lose a minute and perhaps a little pride. If you stay silent and you are right, the patient pays. Speaking up is the cheap option every time, and the safest wards are the ones where a porter can stop a consultant and nobody finds it strange.

The steps below take the fear out by giving you a script that is polite at every level.

Graded assertiveness: four steps

Each step is one level more direct than the last. Start at step one for almost everything. Move up only if the risk remains.

Step 1: the question

Ask as if you are curious, because you may be. The question gives the other person a chance to fix it themselves or to explain what you missed.

  • "Did you want to gel before you go in?"
  • "Is that the right patient? The board says bed 4 is Mr Kimathi."
  • "Should the bed rails be up for her? I thought the plan said no."

Most problems end here. The person says "oh, thanks," fixes it, and the day goes on.

Step 2: the concern

If the answer does not resolve it, say what you are worried about and why. Use "I" and name the risk.

  • "I'm worried, because she had diarrhoea overnight and I think that needs soap, not gel."
  • "I'm concerned that's the wrong patient. Can we check the wristband together?"

Step 3: the challenge

State clearly that you think it is unsafe. Still polite, no longer a question.

  • "I don't think it's safe to go in without washing. I'd like you to wash first."
  • "I'm not comfortable moving him without a second person. The assessment says two."

Some hospitals teach three words for this step: concerned, uncomfortable, safety. "I'm concerned. I'm uncomfortable with this. This is a safety issue." When a colleague hears those three in a row, they know you have moved past the question stage.

Step 4: the stop

Rarely needed, always allowed. You say stop, you do not do the task, and you get someone senior.

  • "Stop. I'm not going to help with this until the nurse in charge has looked."
  • "I'm going to get the nurse in charge now."

Then do it. A stop is not an argument. You do not have to win the discussion; you only have to pause the task until someone with the authority to decide arrives.

Across hierarchy

The words change a little depending on who you are talking to, but the steps do not.

To a nurse, when you are an assistant or a porter. Use their name, keep the question short, and say what you saw. Nurses are used to being asked things and most will thank you.

To a doctor, when you are anyone else. Doctors on a ward round are moving fast and may not look up. Say their name or "Doctor," wait for eye contact, then ask. "Doctor, before you examine her, the gel is just here." If they walk on, step two is still polite: "I'm concerned, she's in isolation for a reason."

To a manager or the nurse in charge. The same words. If they are the one doing the unsafe thing, step two can go straight to "I'm concerned," because they have the authority to decide and need to hear your reason, not a hint.

To someone from another team: theatres, radiology, an agency nurse. They do not know your ward's habits. Lead with the local rule: "On this ward we wash with soap for that side room. The sink is here."

Whoever it is, speak privately when you can. Beside the bed, in front of the patient and the bay, people defend themselves. In the corridor, people listen.

Taking a challenge well

You will be on the receiving end too, probably within your first month. Someone newer than you will ask whether you gelled, or whether that is the right patient. The way you answer teaches the whole ward whether speaking up is safe.

Say "thank you," and check. That is the whole response. Not "I know," not "I was about to," not an explanation. If they were right, fix it. If they were wrong, say "Good spot, but in this case it's fine because ..." and tell them why, so they learn something. Never make the person regret opening their mouth.

A ward where the first-year assistant can question the charge nurse and get a thank you is a ward where the next error gets caught. First time in charge of a shift covers how a new leader sets that tone on day one.

An example about a missed hand wash

Say you are a nursing assistant on a care of the elderly ward. A registrar you have not met before arrives to see Mrs Byrne in side room 1. The sign on the door says contact precautions, apron, gloves, and soap and water on leaving. The registrar pulls on gloves and an apron, examines Mrs Byrne, peels off the gloves and apron, drops them in the bin, pumps gel from the wall, and heads for the next room.

Step one, at the door: "Doctor, did you want to use the sink? That room's soap and water." She says "I've gelled, thanks," and keeps walking.

Step two, two steps behind her, quietly: "I'm concerned, because she's got the diarrhoea bug and the infection team said gel doesn't work for that one. The sink's just here."

She stops, looks at the door sign, and says "You're right, sorry," washes at the sink, and goes on with her round.

Two sentences. Nobody raised a voice. If she had kept walking, step three would have been "I don't think it's safe to see the next patient without washing," and if she had refused, you would have told the nurse in charge, which is step four without any drama at all. The five moments of hand hygiene are the standard she knew and skipped under pressure, and pressure is exactly when a colleague's prompt is worth most.

When this does not work

The person gets angry. Stay at the step you were on. Repeat it once, calmly, in the same words. Then go to the nurse in charge. Anger is not a reason to drop a safety concern, and it is not your job to manage a senior colleague's mood.

You froze and said nothing. It happens, especially on a bad night. The night shift sleep tips for hospital staff matter here, because tiredness is the most common reason people stay silent. Afterwards, report what you saw through your hospital's incident reporting system. It is late, but it still helps the next patient.

It is the same person, every week. One conversation fixes a moment. A pattern needs the nurse in charge or your manager, and most hospitals have a confidential route for staff who are worried about a colleague's practice. Your employer's policy names it. Use it; that is what it is for.

You spoke up and the patient was still harmed. Speaking up does not guarantee the outcome. It gives the team a chance. If the worst happens, coping after a patient dies on shift is for you, and so is the debrief your ward should hold.

The broader guide to working in a hospital for every role puts speaking up alongside handover, breaks and the other habits that keep a shift safe.

Learn this in five minutes

The track Speaking Up for Safety teaches why silence is the most common cause of harm, graded assertiveness from a question to a stop, speaking up across hierarchy, receiving a challenge without defensiveness, and building a ward where speaking up is normal. Five lessons, with the exact words to use.

All articles